Find the Boat That Matches How Your Family Spends Summer

Warm weather has a short shelf life in Indiana, and nobody wants to spend it shopping instead of boating. Our lot is stocked with boats for sale in Indy, IN, from family tritoons to fishing rigs to fiberglass sport boats, and our team is good at matching people with the one that truly fits their weekends.

• New models from Bennington, Avalon, Lund, Four Winns, and Crownline sit alongside a rotating group of quality pre-owned boats.
• Financing help and honest trade-in conversations make the numbers work before you ever hitch up.
• Our service and parts counters keep you on the water long after delivery day.

Reeder-Trausch Marine Indy has been part of the southside boating scene for a long time, with roots going back to 1993. Managing partners J Westley Hurless and Monty Anderson added this store to the family in 2024, and the feel of the place says a lot about how they run things. Buying a boat is a big decision, and we would rather it be exciting than intimidating.

Being family-owned means you get real answers, and you can ask twice if you want. Sitting near US 37 and I-69 puts us about an hour from Geist, Morse, and Monroe, so shopping on a Saturday and launching on a Sunday is a completely reasonable plan.

New and Used Boats for Sale in Indy, IN

Our new boat lineup leans hard into pontoons and tritoons, because that is what central Indiana asks for. Bennington and Avalon cover the cruising and entertaining side, and the Bennington M Series brings layouts and features that surprise even longtime owners. Lund takes care of the fishing crowd with aluminum hulls built for early mornings and choppy afternoons. Four Winns and Crownline round things out for buyers who want fiberglass performance and a bowrider that can pull a skier all day. Power comes from Mercury, MerCruiser, Suzuki, and Yamaha.

Not every budget starts at new, and that is perfectly fine. Our pre-owned selection covers pontoons, fishing boats, and sport boats that our technicians have gone through before anything reaches the lot. Plenty of first-time buyers start right here, get a season or two behind them, then trade up. Browse what is available online, then come walk the rows and see how the layouts feel in person.

Financing and Trade-Ins Without the Guesswork

Our finance team works with lenders who understand boats, which matters more than most people expect. Terms, seasonal payment planning, and how a trade changes the math all get explained in plain language, so you know what a monthly number really looks like before you commit to anything. Active and retired military members from the US and Canada get a discount as well.

If you already own a boat, bring us the details, and we will talk trade. There is no automated tool doing the guessing here. We look at your boat, tell you what it is worth to us, and put that toward whatever comes next. Reach out with the year, make, model, and hours to get the conversation started.

Service and Parts from a Team That Knows Your Rig

Monty runs the service side, and our technicians handle everything from routine maintenance to the tricky problems other shops send away. Winterization, detailing, hauling, and indoor storage are all part of what we do, so your boat has somewhere to go when the season winds down. Call to get on the schedule before the spring rush fills it up.

The parts counter keeps the everyday items on hand and can order the rest. Props, covers, tow ropes, electronics, and the upgrades that make a good boat feel like yours. Every boat we sell also comes with an on-the-water orientation, where we show you how to back down the ramp, dock, tie up, and load back onto the trailer. That one hour saves a lot of frustration at a busy launch.

Boats and Services Under One Roof

Here is a quick look at what we carry and what we handle after the sale.

Boating works best when one place handles it all. Shopping, financing, rigging, service, storage, and the July phone call when something is not quite right. That is the setup we have built here, and it is a big reason a lot of our customers are on their third or fourth boat with us.

Boating Made Easy at Reeder-Trausch Marine Indy

We are a family-owned shop with a young, energetic crew, and we treat customers the way we would want to be treated. Teamwork, accountability, and keeping our promises are the three values our own staff voted on, and they hold up day after day. Whether you are looking at boats for sale for the very first time or know which tritoon you want, we will give you room to decide and answers whenever you need them.

Stop by and walk the lot, or give us a call and tell us what your family likes to do out on the water. We will take it from there.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kinds of boats for sale can I find at Reeder-Trausch Marine Indy?

We carry pontoons, tritoons, fishing boats, bowriders, and sport cruisers, both new and pre-owned. Our new lineup includes Bennington, Avalon, Lund, Four Winns, and Crownline. Tell us how many people you usually have aboard and what your family likes to do on the water, and we can narrow it down fast.

Do you sell used boats?

Yes, and pre-owned sales are a big part of what we do. Every used boat goes through our service department before it reaches the lot, so you know what you are getting. It is a practical way into ownership when a new boat is not the right fit for the budget.

Can I trade in my current boat?

You can. Contact us with the year, make, model, and engine hours on your boat, and we will discuss trade options with you directly. We would rather look at the real boat and give you a straight answer than hand you a number from an online estimator.

Does Reeder-Trausch Marine Indy have a service department?

We do, and it handles everything from routine maintenance and winterization to detailing, hauling, and storage. Our technicians work on the brands we sell and plenty of brands we do not. Give us a call to get on the schedule, especially heading into spring when the calendar fills up.

What if I have never owned a boat before?

First-time buyers make up a healthy share of our customers, so you are in good company. Every boat we sell comes with an on-the-water orientation covering ramp launching, docking, tying up, and loading back onto the trailer. Ask as many questions as you want, because that is exactly what we are here for.

Where can I see boats for sale in person?

Our showroom and lot in Indy, IN, are open Monday through Saturday, and you are welcome to walk through without an appointment. Come see the layouts for yourself, since photos never quite capture how a deck feels once you are standing on it.